Fee structures for business brokers in Australia: retainers, success fees and what to invoice when
Unbroken · · 6 min read
Business brokers in Australia are paid mostly by a success fee, a percentage of the sale price payable at settlement, often with an upfront or monthly retainer and a minimum fee. What to invoice when follows from the engagement letter: the retainer on signing, any valuation or IM fee on delivery, and the success fee on completion, with disbursements passed through as they are incurred.
What are the common fee structures for business brokers?
- Success fee only: a percentage of the sale price, typically higher for smaller businesses and tapering as value rises. Simple, and it means the broker carries the cost of a mandate that does not sell.
- Retainer plus success fee: an upfront or monthly fee that covers the preparation work (valuation, IM, market mapping), usually credited against the success fee at settlement. Common for mid-sized mandates where the preparation is substantial.
- Sliding scale: a higher percentage on the first tranche of price and lower percentages on higher tranches (the Lehman formula), or the reverse, so the broker earns more for exceeding a target. The reverse form aligns better with the seller's interest.
- Minimum fee: a floor on the success fee so that a small sale still covers the work. State it in dollars in the engagement letter.
- Fixed fees for defined deliverables: a business appraisal, a full valuation, an exit readiness review or an IM, priced and invoiced on delivery whether or not a sale follows.
Disbursements (advertising, data room, legal review of the IM, travel) are separate and should be listed in the engagement letter as pass-through costs, with an approval threshold above which the seller signs off first.
What should the engagement letter define?
Most fee disputes come from ambiguity, not bad faith. The letter should define the sale price on which the fee is calculated (does it include stock, earn-outs, deferred consideration, assumed debt, a lease premium?), when the fee is payable (settlement, not exchange), what happens on a partial sale, and the tail: the period after the mandate ends during which a sale to a buyer the broker introduced still earns the fee. Six to twelve months is common. It should also say whether the retainer is credited against the success fee and whether GST is on top.
The AIBB Code of Conduct requires members to disclose fees and charges in writing before an engagement, and each state's business agent licensing regime has its own requirements for agency agreements. Get the letter reviewed once by a lawyer and then reuse it.
What do you invoice at each stage of a mandate?
Invoicing in a brokerage should be event-driven, not calendar-driven. Each event in the mandate has an invoice that belongs to it, or explicitly does not.
- On signing the engagement: the retainer or the first monthly retainer, and any fixed fee for the appraisal or valuation if it is billed in advance.
- On delivery of the valuation report or the IM: the fixed fee for that deliverable, if it was not billed in advance.
- Monthly during the mandate: the monthly retainer if there is one, and disbursements incurred that month with receipts attached.
- On exchange of contracts: usually nothing. Some brokers invoice a portion of the success fee on exchange; most sellers resist, and settlement is the safer trigger.
- On settlement: the success fee, calculated on the defined sale price, less any retainer credit, plus GST. The invoice should be ready before the day so the settlement statement can include it, and paid from the settlement funds where the contract and the seller's solicitor allow.
- After the tail: nothing, unless a sale to an introduced buyer completes inside the tail period.
Every invoice should name the deal, the fee item and the triggering event. An invoice that says 'professional services' invites a query; one that says 'Success fee, sale of the business, settled 14 August, 4 per cent of A$1,850,000' does not.
How do you keep the billing clean?
Keep a fee schedule per firm so a new invoice picks the deal and the fee item rather than typing a description. Draft the invoice in the accounting system the brokerage already uses; if that is Xero, draft it there directly, with a pay link on it, so it appears in the debtors ledger without re-keying. Xero's own guidance on online payment services covers the pay-link options. Reconcile fee income against the pipeline monthly: every deal marked settled should have a success fee invoice, and every success fee invoice should have a settled deal.
Tax invoices must meet the ATO's requirements, including the words 'tax invoice', the ABN, the date, a description, and the GST amount or a statement that the total includes GST. Where the brokerage holds client money (a deposit on a private sale, for instance), it goes into a trust account under the state's agency rules, with a ledger per deal, and it is never mixed with fee income.
Unbroken's client billing keeps a fee schedule per firm, drafts invoices in Xero against the deal, records every Stripe payment against the client invoice, and keeps a trust account ledger that only an administrator can touch, so a brokerage's own billing is as traceable as the valuations it sells.
How do fees interact with the price?
A sliding scale that rises with price changes the broker's incentive at the margin, and sellers notice. A flat percentage is easier to explain. A retainer reduces the broker's exposure on a mandate that does not sell but can be read by the seller as a lack of confidence. There is no universally right answer; the right answer is the one stated plainly, in writing, before the work starts. The success-fee calculator in the tools set lets a seller see the fee at a range of prices, which is often the quickest way to settle the conversation.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage do business brokers charge in Australia?
It varies with the size of the business and the state, and there is no regulated rate. Smaller businesses attract a higher percentage than larger ones, and many brokers use a sliding scale. The engagement letter, not a rule of thumb, sets the fee.
Is the success fee payable on exchange or settlement?
Usually on settlement, when the seller has the funds. Some agreements provide for part on exchange. Whichever it is, the engagement letter must say so, and the invoice should be prepared before settlement day so it can be paid from the proceeds.
Is GST charged on broker fees?
Yes, a GST-registered broker charges GST on fees, and the invoice must be a valid tax invoice. Whether the sale of the business itself is GST-free as a going concern is a separate question that concerns the seller and buyer, not the broker's fee.
What is a tail period?
The period after an engagement ends during which the broker still earns the success fee if the business sells to a buyer the broker introduced. It protects the broker from a seller who ends the mandate to avoid the fee. Six to twelve months is typical.
Can a broker take the fee out of the deposit?
Only if the agency agreement and the state's rules allow it, and only from trust money that has been released in accordance with the contract. Otherwise the fee is invoiced and paid from settlement funds. Never treat trust money as fee income before it is released.
Sources & further reading
Written by the Unbroken team, following a Registered Business Valuer's framework. The valuer stays responsible for the opinion.