What a defensible business valuation looks like (and why buyers' advisers pull the others apart)
Unbroken · · 7 min read
A defensible business valuation is one a buyer's accountant can rebuild from the report and the source documents and arrive at the same number, or at least at the same reasoning. It states the basis and premise of value, shows every adjustment to earnings with its evidence, explains why it chose its primary method and what the cross-checks say, and traces each figure back to the line in the accounts it came from.
Why do buyers' advisers pull valuations apart?
Because it is their job, and because it is usually easy. A buyer's accountant is paid to find the reasons the price should be lower. A valuation that gives them a loose add-back, an unexplained multiple or an earnings figure that does not reconcile to the accounts hands them the argument. The seller then negotiates from a position of having been caught, and the price moves further than the item was worth.
The common findings are predictable. Add-backs that are really recurring costs. An owner's salary replaced with a figure below what a manager would cost. The best year of three treated as the maintainable year. A multiple asserted rather than derived. Working capital ignored, so the price moves at completion. Three methods averaged to hide the fact that none was trusted. And figures that appear in the report but not in any statement the buyer can see.
What must a defensible valuation state?
- The basis of value: usually Market Value, defined as in the International Valuation Standards, and not synergistic or investment value unless a specific buyer is named. Our post on Market Value covers why this matters.
- The premise of value: going concern, or orderly or forced liquidation. A trading business valued on a going-concern basis while the report quietly assumes the assets are sold separately is not defensible.
- The valuation date and the information relied on, with the date of each financial statement and whether it was audited, reviewed or management-prepared.
- The scope and purpose, and any limitations. A valuation for a sale is not a valuation for tax, family law or a shareholder dispute, and the report should say what it is for.
- Who did it and under what standard. In Australia, APES 225 governs accountants' valuation services, and the Registered Business Valuer credential signals training in the market for private businesses.
The ATO's guidance on market valuation makes the same points from the regulator's side: a valuation must be objective, supportable and documented, and one done by a professional valuer is more credible than one that is not.
How should adjustments be shown?
Every add-back and every negative adjustment on its own line, with the amount in each year, the source line in the P&L, the reason, and an assessment of how defensible it is. A buyer's adviser will accept an owner's above-market salary reversed to a market rate if the market rate is evidenced. They will not accept 'miscellaneous', or a discretionary expense added back with no explanation. The schedule has to run both ways: an under-paid family member's wages are a negative adjustment, and a valuation that lists only positive ones is a sales document, not a valuation.
The test is simple: could the buyer's accountant, given the P&L and the schedule, tick each item? If any line requires the valuer to be in the room to explain it, it is not yet defensible.
How should the valuation method be chosen and explained?
Choose a primary method because it fits the business, say why, and use the others as cross-checks. For most trading businesses in Australia, a capitalisation of maintainable earnings is primary, with a market approach from comparable transactions and industry multiples as a check, and a discounted cash flow where the future is expected to differ materially from the past. An asset-based approach is the floor, and the primary method only when earnings do not support the assets.
Then explain the differences. If the market cross-check gives a number 15 per cent below the primary method, say why the primary is preferred and what that implies about the multiple. Do not average: a reader can see through an average, and it tells them the valuer did not know which method to trust.
What does 'linked to its source' mean in practice?
It means that any number in the report can be followed back to a statement the buyer has. Revenue in the summary table to the P&L. Normalised EBITDA to the reported EBITDA plus the schedule. The multiple to the comparable set or the industry range with its source. The working capital peg to the balance sheets. If the report was built in a spreadsheet, that trail is a set of cell references nobody else can read. If it was built in a system that links each figure to its source line and keeps a decision log of every judgement, the trail is the report.
That is the standard Unbroken's valuation module is built to: statements connected from Xero or uploaded, add-backs scanned line by line and rated for defensibility, a primary method with cross-checks, the basis and premise declared on the deal, and an automatic defensibility check that flags anything a buyer's accountant or a reviewing valuer would challenge before the report is approved.
What happens when the valuation is defensible?
The negotiation is about price, not about the numbers. A buyer's adviser who rebuilds the earnings and gets the same figure moves on to the multiple, and the multiple is a matter of judgement on which reasonable people differ by a turn or so. The seller keeps the ground they started on. And the broker's IM, which was drafted from the same facts, does not contradict the report. A defensible valuation is not the one with the highest number; it is the one the price ends up closest to.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an appraisal and a valuation?
An appraisal is an opinion of likely selling price, usually shorter and prepared for a seller deciding whether to go to market. A valuation is a fuller report prepared to a recognised standard, stating its basis of value, method and evidence. Both should be defensible; a valuation is expected to be.
Should a valuation include the seller's forecasts?
Only where the method relies on them, such as a discounted cash flow, and then with the assumptions stated and tested against past trading. A capitalisation of maintainable earnings should rest on historical earnings adjusted for known changes, not on a forecast.
How many years of accounts does a defensible valuation need?
Three financial years plus current-year management accounts is the usual minimum. Fewer than three makes it hard to distinguish a maintainable level from a good year; more helps for cyclical businesses. Each year should be identified as audited, reviewed or management-prepared.
Is a valuation by the seller's accountant defensible?
It can be, if it follows APES 225 and states its basis, method and evidence. A buyer's adviser will apply more scepticism to it because of the relationship, so the documentation has to work harder. An independent valuer's report avoids that question.
What is a defensibility check?
A structured review of a valuation against the questions an adversarial reader would ask: is the basis stated, does every adjustment have evidence, is the method choice explained, do the cross-checks reconcile, does every figure link to its source. It can be done by a second valuer or, in part, automatically.
Sources & further reading
Written by the Unbroken team, following a Registered Business Valuer's framework. The valuer stays responsible for the opinion.